• Celebrate Valentine's Day with Us

    Celebrate Valentine's Day with Us

    Friday, February 13 – Sunday, February 15

    VIEW MENU

  • Commodore Cares Friday Night

    Commodore Cares Friday Night

    Learn More

  • Celebrating 50 Years of Caymus

    Celebrating 50 Years of Caymus

    View Menu

  • Treat Yourself to Sunday Brunch

    Treat Yourself to Sunday Brunch

    A three-course dining experience

    View brunch menu

  • A historic waterfront property

    A historic waterfront property

    Experience the nostalgia on Nagawicka Lake.

    Make your reservation

  • Timeless American Classics

    Timeless American Classics

    Our menu blends nostalgic favorites with a fresh, contemporary style.

    Make your reservation

Bartolotta Rewards members earn Reward Points in the restaurant and when hosting private dining restaurant events.
Currently, Bartolotta Rewards cannot be redeemed at this particular location.
COM-Happy-Hour-2025.jpg

Happy Hour at The Commodore

Cheers to happy hour! Gather your friends and enjoy a glass of wine or cocktail and one of our specialty appetizers while you take in the stunning views of Nagawicka Lake.

Learn More
Valentines---Digital_FINAL_V3-1.jpg

Join us for Valentine's Day

Make your reservation today to celebrate the one you love with an exquisite dinner prepared by Executive Chef Scott Garthwaite and his team.

Learn More
COM-Wine_Enthusiast_Web_Specials_Thumbnail.png

Wine Enthusiast's Top 50 New Restaurants 2025

We are honored to receive national recognition for both our restaurant's culinary excellence and wine program.

Learn More

TUESDAY - SATURDAY •  4:30 – 9 PM

SUNDAY  •  
Brunch 10 AM - 2 PM & Dinner  4:30 – 9 PM

HAPPY HOUR  •  Tuesday – Friday 3 - 5 PM

Bartolotta Rewards members earn Reward Points in the restaurant and when hosting private dining restaurant events.  Currently, Bartolotta Rewards cannot be redeemed at this particular location.

1807 Nagawicka Road, Hartland, WI 53029