FAQs Joey Gerard's Frequently Asked Questions
Joey Gerard's – A Bartolotta Supper Club is a nostalgic casual dining destination in historic Greendale that features steaks, chops and seafood cooked in Josper charcoal ovens offering classic supper club menu options, classic cocktails and ice cream drinks in a warm atmosphere with dark leather booths and vintage charm.
Hours & Days of Operation
What are the hours and days of operation for Joey Gerard's?
MONDAY - SATURDAY • 5 - 9 PM
HAPPY HOUR | MONDAY - FRIDAY • 4 - 6 PM
Location
Where is Joey Gerard's located?
Joey Gerard's is located at 5601 Broad St, Greendale, WI 53129
Parking
What parking options are available at Joey Gerard's?
We invite you to park with us in our restaurant’s on-site parking lot.
Dress Code
What is the dress code at Joey Gerard's?
We invite you to dress to impress and put your best foot forward as you join us for dinner—polished, put-together, and sophisticated attire is encouraged. We warmly welcome all guests and believe that everyone can express their personal style while contributing to our refined dining atmosphere.
Menu
What type of menu does Joey Gerard's offer?
Signature menu items you can experience at Joey Gerard's – A Bartolotta Supper Club include Joey’s Relish Tray, Joey’s Fried Seafood Platter, or their variety of Steaks and Chops.
Food allergy and dietary restriction accommodations
Does Joey Gerard's accommodate food allergies or dietary restrictions?
Please make your server or event planner aware of any allergies or dietary restrictions you may have so they can better accommodate the dining experience.
How to Make a Reservation
How can I make a reservation at Joey Gerard's?
You can make a reservation at bartolottas.com/joey-gerards/make-a-reservation or by calling 414-858-1900
Large Party Reservations
How do I make a large party reservation?
To make a large party reservation for 9 or more, please call Joey Gerard's at 414-858-1900, so our team can organize the best dining experience for your group.
Patio Dining
Does Joey Gerard's offer patio dining?
A seasonal outdoor patio, open typically between Memorial Day and Labor Day, has plenty of tables to enjoy the summer season with your loved ones. Patio dining operates on a first-come, first-served basis, though reservations are accepted.
Indoor dining is not guaranteed during inclement weather.
How to plan a Private Dining Event
How can I plan a private dining event at Joey Gerard's?
Rely on the expertise of Bartolotta event planners to create a flawless family gathering, special event or unforgettable wedding day. To start the private dining event planning process by submitting an event information request form on our website, emailing sales@bartolottas.com, or by calling 414-935-5014.
